Tuesday, September 10, 2013

Inclusive Staff Meetings

This afternoon, we had our first 'official' faculty meeting with our staff at my new school, Sa-Hali Secondary School.  On Opening Day, we met briefly to discuss some technical tidbits to get the school up and running, but this was our first real chance to learn together as a large group.  I was quite excited, and a bit nervous as well:  I know that staff meetings can often be known as the rapid remedy for insomnia, and I was eager to ensure that our faculty meetings would not be similarly characterized.

Last year I wrote a post called "Owning Staff Meetings", a piece that I composed to challenge myself to create inquiry-based activities that would engage our staff in the co-creation of engaging staff meetings and model ideas that staff could use in their own classroom.  From that post:

"I wanted to create an inquiry activity that would allow our staff collaborate together to collectively come up with ideas on how to increase staff engagement.  There were a few reasons for us to do it this way:
  • We want to continue to have or staff learn different techniques to effectively engage their students in class discussions
  • We want to continue to expose our staff to collaborative technologies that maximize engagement and interactions between participants
  • We want to get authentic staff input
  • We really don't know the answers to the questions that we were asking our staff about making effective staff meetings for our staff."
After adopting this philosophy, I found that an inquiry-based approach was significantly more effective in increasing the number of interactions between staff members and in increasing the number of staff members that were meaningfully contributing to group discussions.  Bearing this in mind, I wanted to do the same thing at my first staff meeting this year--to create an activity that allowed us as a staff to 'own' our staff meetings.

However, while I have my own thoughts about what characterizes a productive and meaningful meeting, these thoughts could be entirely different than the vision our staff might have.  So I created a Google Form called "Meetings-From Not So Great To Great", and had our staff work collaborate in small groups to characterize ineffective and effective meeting conditions.  In order for the staff to get an immediate, visual sense of their efforts, I took the data from the form and put it into a word cloud while they were finishing the activity.  (So not only was our staff collaborating, we were modelling the use of technologies that we could use tomorrow in classrooms).  The results told a story for me and for our staff:

So that we could begin to frame a positive image, we also created a word cloud depicting the elements of more effective meetings:


I really liked some of the words that we used here, and the one that really resonated with me was "inclusive".  It made me realize that although we are professionals, we cannot take for granted that we automatically have a meeting environment where people feel safe in speaking up,  thinking differently, taking risks and thinking out loud.  Interestingly, we often do this with our students in our classrooms: we work together to co-create student-developed guiding documents, and then post them on our walls as a reminder and reference point when the tone of our classes moves away from the desired norm. In a completely teachable moment, our Social Justice teacher pulled me in to his classroom right off of the library where we were meeting and showed me what he created with his Grade 12 class:


I believe that commitments such as these are very important for students, and just as important for us as adults and educators.  I had the teacher describe to all of us about how he did this with his class, and also how much time he spent doing it.  I was not surprised to hear that it was a couple of weeks at the start of the year--it is that important to spend the time making sure people are safe.

With this authentic example in our minds, we worked again in small groups on a Google Doc called "Staff Meeting Commitment Brainstorming" in which our entire staff worked together to draft ideas for commitments to make our faculty meetings safe for all of us.  A number of faculty members had never worked simultaneously and collaboratively on a digital document such as this in such a large group, and it was amazing to see every staff member engaged in meaningful dialogue with their peers.  And I even had one staff member say that it was nice to work on a digital document because she felt it truly gave her a voice on staff!  Honestly, I actually had to stop the group so that we could end the meeting so that people could get home for dinner.

Early in my career, in the interests of not wanting to 'take too much time on this stuff', I would have taken all of the information myself and tried to sort, classify, paraphrase, and make inferences in a process to pare down the information we had gathered into palatable chunks for the staff. At that point, I would have moved the commitments in a direction that I felt we needed to go, truncated the whole exercise, and moved on.  Without malice and in the interests of time, I would have inadvertently hi-jacked the process.

#badidea
#notgonnadoit

Like any school, we have hundreds of years of experience on our staff.  Our Coordinators are highly motivated, creative problem-seekers and solvers that are tremendously invested in their students, their classrooms, and their colleagues.  So regardless of how long the process takes, we will involve our entire staff in making a set of commitments that will allow everyone to be a contributing, engaged and valued staff member during our faculty meetings.  The information that we collected will come to our Coordinators, who will help to design an exercise with all of the feedback we collected that

  • requires the engagement of each staff member 
  • models the use of higher order critical thinking skills for our staff (interpretation, prediction, selection, synthesis, etc) in an exercise they can adapt and apply to their classes 
  • leads to the implementation of a tangible product (such as the chart from our Social Justice class) that is reflective of each of our voices, and subsequently guides us for all of our future staff meetings
  • has them touch a piece of technology so that the exercise can be as efficient and replicated/archived (in our Sa-Hali Educational Sandbox, which we just created yesterday!) for future use in classrooms or collaborative meetings.
It is tempting to make faculty meetings short.  It is easy to make them places where we rapidly disseminate information.  It is difficult not to succumb to the allure of getting people 'in and out' so all of us can get on with our busy lives.  But it is one of the only times that we can get together and learn with and from each other.  If we want our faculty meetings to truly be an environment where people feel safe in speaking up, thinking differently, taking risks and thinking out loud, then I am realizing there are no short cuts in creating an inclusive climate that not only enables but encourages innovation and applauds taking chances.

I look forward to helping co-create our future faculty meetings with our Coordinators and staff.  If you have any suggestions as to how to create an even more inclusive staff environment, please comment!




5 comments:

  1. Have I ever mentioned how badly I want to work with/for you, Cale?

    This is YET another reminder that you are an incredible school leader.

    Hope you're doing well. It's been WAY too long.

    Let's get a hangout going so I can bask in your brilliance.

    Rock right on,
    Bill

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks Bill! Looking forward to seeing you in Vancouver next month!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Cale! You reminded me of an "aha" moment when I was teaching senior economics a few decades ago. I realized the very real truth of needing to go slow in order to go fast. Taking time to establish relationships, processes, meaning, and culture in the beginning of class (or any group endeavour) takes a significant amount of time in the beginning, but saves much more time, and increases effectiveness over the course of the year(s). Thanks for reminding me!

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I’m reminded of the Lord of the rings quote – “Nothing said before the word ‘but’ really counts.
    homeschoolersforken.com |

    penthousewilliamsburg.com |

    housesineastoxford.com |

    ronthomhome4sale.com |

    paradise-house.com |

    ReplyDelete

Thanks for taking the time to comment on my blog!