Sunday, October 21, 2012

Don't Get In To Classrooms Enough? Create 'Windows'!

"I wish I could get into classrooms more than I do right now".

While likely not a hundred percent of administrators, I am sure that most Principals and Vice-Principals have had this phrase pass through their lips at one point or another during the course of their career.  With the demands of student dealings, teacher questions, parent conferences, meetings with district personnel, break and lunch supervision, and the seemingly endless avalanche of paperwork that falls on to their desks, administrators can easily be crushed under the weight of day-to-day operations in their schools.  I am not complaining--it's just a reality sometimes.  Like many teachers and administrators in education, I often find myself creating a 'to-do list' before the day starts, and by the time the day ends, I not only have accomplished exactly none of my must-do tasks for the day, I actually have a few new ones tacked on.  And suddenly getting into classrooms, one of my favourite and most important pieces of my job as an administrator, falls off of the side of my desk.

But there are some different ways that I try to 'get into the classroom' that don't involve my physically being there.  I can do some things later in the evening, once my kids have gone to bed.  One of these ways I try to create a 'window' into the classrooms of our 80 teachers is through reading and providing feedback on the syllabus for their courses, or course outlines.  "Course outlines?", you say, "Aren't they those boring one sheeters that tend to be the first thing to rip out of a student's binder?  No one pays attention to those.".  I grant you that in the past, I might have agreed with that.  However, that was my fault.  I rarely looked at them unless there was some sort of issue in the classroom, and I certainly never discussed them with the teacher.  But four years ago, I decided that if I was going to request them, and teachers were going to go through the effort of doing them, they deserved my feedback.

I believe that course outlines need to serve a number of purposes for students and parents:
  • They need to inform the student and the parent, in student-friendly language
    • the specific skills and outcomes that they will have learned by the end of the course
    • the methods by which the outcomes will be evaluated
    • the supports and interventions that will be in place should they struggle with learning those outcomes
    • the means by which students can accelerate should they master the outcomes
  • They need to detail a communication protocol with the student and the parent that demonstrates frequent, two-way dialogue
    • with the teacher's email provided, and the parent's email sought so that asynchronous communication can take place, rather than the dreaded 'telephone tag'
    • with an indication of regular progress updates to regularly inform students and parents about how a student is meeting the learning outcomes of the course
    • with suggestions about how parents can be positively involved in supporting their student.
  • They need to get the student and the parent excited about the course!  I like to think that we never see our courses as 'mandatory'.  We should approach our courses as electives, where we are 'marketing' our course to students in a way that gets them pumped up and engaged before they even start the class!
But course outlines also serve several purposes for me in terms of starting a conversation with the teacher in a number of areas:
  • Learning Outcomes:  By looking at the outline and outlines of other members of a department, I can start the conversation with the teacher about whether they have used collaboratively agreed upon outcomes for their course that will prepare students for success at subsequent levels of that subject area.  We can talk about designing down and scaffolding.  We can discuss the concept of assignments versus outcomes.  We can look at how the outcomes that they have listed match up with not only the department, but with the curriculum guidelines laid out by the provincial government.  We can look at the number of outcomes that the teacher is trying to cover.  We can discuss resources that will help them engage their students.  We can dialogue about 'struggle points'--those outcomes that students tend to struggle with and ways to ameliorate those problem areas to ensure student success.
  • Assessment Practices:  The course outline indicates how students will be assessed.  When reading the outline, I can start a conversation about assessing by outcome/skill rather than assessment tool.  It is always a lively discussion when we chat about 'tests worth 60%' rather than 'oral expression skills worth 40%, written language expression worth 40%, etc' in a language course.  Or to talk about the '40% Term 1, 40% for Term 2, 20% Final Exam' model versus a model that recognizes that students learn at different rates.  Or about toxic grading practices such as late marks.  We can also talk about how the staff member uses the assessments that they give to students to inform their practice.  These are just a few of the endless rich conversations that can take place around assessment.
  • Interventions and Accommodations:  By looking at the course outlines, I can get a sense of how our teachers ensure student success.  Whether it is through methods that they have created to give students multiple opportunities to demonstrate outcomes, or if it is utilizing one the many mechanisms in our timetable, I can work with the teacher to help them support the students who learn at different rates in their classrooms.
And these are just some of the conversations we can have!

Much like our staff does with our students, I like to give guidelines for our teachers to work with each June when they are preparing their course outlines for the following year.  I use this Course Outline Checklist as a set of statements for teachers to reflect upon their outlines and modify them for the next school year.  At the beginning of our semesters in September and February, I collect the outlines, and try to give feedback on them in the first few weeks of the year.  I use the same form to give feedback (here is a sample), as well as making comments and using colors to indicate strengths and areas for improvement. 

With 80 teachers, many of whom teach different courses in multiple departments, this process can take a long time. Furthermore, many of our staff members have created their own blogs, which takes the course outline to another level, and I love giving feedback on those as well, but not all of our teachers are there yet.  But the conversations that I can have with our staff as a result of their course outlines can be incredibly rich and worthwhile.  Not a visit to the classroom, I grant you, but certainly meaningful nonetheless.

In the final analysis, if you (like me) feel like you are not in classrooms as much as you like, take the opportunity to create your own 'windows' into classrooms.  You will be pleasantly surprised at what you see!


  1. Hi Cale
    I remember my first year as Principal and asking for Course Outlines.
    Reading them all over, carefully , and responding to each of them individually through email and face to face with teachers.

    Rather than a document filed away for episodes of "in case," the outlines became invitations to discussion around the three areas you have highlighted in you post.

    The reactions? A few teachers came to me office to thank me because they had never received feedback to a course outline. Others came forward to discuss the tips or suggestions I had emailed them. In other words, the course outline became a vehicle for professionally engaging dialogue which centred on best practices in our school. It also served to put forward, in practice, my belief that the Principal is an educational leader in the school community.

    With regard to parents and course outlines, what we started to do was send course outlines home to parent emails provided to us. When I left JO, the move was towards placing a "Feeds" and "Follow Me" icon on course outlines that would direct parents to both a teacher's blog and our school site/twitter feed.

    Windows to classsroom? Absolutely. Funny, as a Principal you have to also remember that as the chief "learning" custodian, you have to ensure that the windows are cleaned (balancing that management with the ed leadership) so that everyone can see inside. Placing importance on those course outlines does just that.

  2. Hi Cale,

    Thanks for sharing this. As I read your post, I found myself thinking along these lines. What do you think?

    Is it better to have 1 Education Professional assess the course outlines of 80 other Education Professionals, or to have 80 Education Professionals assess each other's course outlines? Share their own checklists and other assessment tools?

    Assessment for learning and effective teaching strategies work for Education Professionals as well as for students; we are all learners.

    21st Century "transformation" applies to education governance and administration structures/processes just as much as it applies to curriculum, pedagogy and the classroom.

    When will 21C "transformation" also improve upon "old school" paradigms culturally embedded in our governance and administration systems, from "sage on the stage", from "star topology", from "top-down", to something more distributed/matrixed, more networked, more collegial, more collaborative, more mutually respectful, more efficient, more effective, more realistic, more professional?

    Chris Kennedy and the BC GELP team summarized it this way.

  3. This blog is really informative for students who learn online. Thanks for sharing information with us regarding Homework Assignment Help keep continue.

  4. I dig this, Pal.

    You can also use your course outlines to figure out how to spend your professional development time and dollars. They'll give you a better sense for the strengths and weaknesses of your staff -- and of their professional interests.

    Finally, your course outlines sound like they give teachers a real opportunity for reflecting on just what they want kids to know and be able to do in their classes. That's valuable in and of itself. Far too many teachers spend far too little time reflecting on those kinds of questions.

    Hope you're well!

  5. coach outlet online coach outlet shop coach factory outlet coach outlet online coach factory outlet coach outlet York offer coach factory outlet online Save big at coach outlet stores coach factory outlet online coach store nearest you coach outlet coach outlet on line store coach factory outlet coach factory outlet fall 2014 coach factory Save big at coach outlet stores coach handbags coach handbags and other designer coach outlet store online coach outlet fall 2014 coach outlet online coach outlet York offer coach factory outlet online coach factory outlet bags coach outlet store online coach outlet store online fall 2014 official coach factory outlet ohio state strength coach coach outlet online ohio state strength coach coach outlet coach outlet usa coach black friday coach outlet on line store coach shoes, handbags, flats, boots, flip flops coach factory outlet coach factory outlet kate spade outlet online kate spade new york handbags kate spade handbags kate spade handbags kate spade outlet online kate spade online shopping kate spade black friday kate spade black friday michael kors outlet michael kors. sign In michael kors outlet online michael kors outlet store 60 % off michael kors outlet michael kors outlet online or In-store michael kors outlet michael kors outlet durable and affordable michael kors outlet michael kors. sign In michael kors black friday michael kors black friday michael kors handbags

  6. My brother recommended I may like this blog. He was once totally right. This submit actually made my day. You can not believe just how a lot time I had spent for this information! Thanks! |

    tourbystudent | | | |


Thanks for taking the time to comment on my blog!